{ "schema_version": 1, "evidence_id": "NB-PUBLIC-CLAIMS-20261010", "reviewed_on": "2026-10-10", "website_source_commit": "e43f046c0027cbcea3b5bd72081e55c81caa1fab", "audit_scope": "Public claims, original-record integrity, current candidate PR metadata and one pinned source inspection; no runtime or live-state execution.", "closure_policy": "Never erase a failure. A recorded local repair, a successful CI check or an open PR does not establish operating closure. Current status applies only to the named scope and observation date.", "records": [ { "id": "NB-SOURCE-20261010-INIT", "kind": "SOURCE_FINDING", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "repository": "NeuroPublic", "source_commit": "b903a9eef25e17ee4fca6089d85e38b0ab9b5e45", "source_file": "src/neuropublic/engine/brain/stale_daemon_detector.py", "source_sha256": "197d3eb106ef816ce58ab33e627e7c71c34c283af562147418f345fcd31ab550", "symbol": "stale_daemon_detector.run_once_sync", "finding": "STATE_FILE_FILTER_EXCLUDES_STANDALONE_HEARTBEAT", "scope": "stale_daemon_detector.run_once_sync source before a domain state exists", "detail": "The pinned source enumerates JSON files but continues unless a filename ends in _state.json. Companion heartbeat processing is reached after that state-file selection. A standalone initialization heartbeat therefore does not enter this scan. This is a source inspection; no runtime incident or current installation was observed." }, { "id": "NB-PR-20261010-4916", "kind": "PR_METADATA", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "repository": "NeuroPublic", "reference": "NeuroPublic #4916", "source_commit": "5918e95232754e48d178f37249528526215c2dc5", "state": "open", "draft": true, "merged": false, "checks": [ { "name": "test", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "5918e95232754e48d178f37249528526215c2dc5" }, { "name": "regression", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "5918e95232754e48d178f37249528526215c2dc5" }, { "name": "lint", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "5918e95232754e48d178f37249528526215c2dc5" } ], "skipped_checks": [ "build-docker", "affected-tests" ], "detail": "Named exact-head CI completed successfully. The PR remains open, Draft and unmerged. Skipped checks were not evaluated. Session ownership and operating adoption were not established." }, { "id": "NB-PR-20261010-4923", "kind": "PR_METADATA", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "repository": "NeuroPublic", "reference": "NeuroPublic #4923", "source_commit": "87400402b7839632bed2bd8fbefa4b0a2856cf82", "state": "open", "draft": true, "merged": false, "checks": [ { "name": "test", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "87400402b7839632bed2bd8fbefa4b0a2856cf82" }, { "name": "regression", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "87400402b7839632bed2bd8fbefa4b0a2856cf82" }, { "name": "lint", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "87400402b7839632bed2bd8fbefa4b0a2856cf82" } ], "skipped_checks": [ "build-docker" ], "detail": "Named exact-head CI completed successfully. The PR remains open, Draft and unmerged. Skipped checks were not evaluated. Session ownership and operating adoption were not established." }, { "id": "NB-PR-20261010-4929", "kind": "PR_METADATA", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "repository": "NeuroPublic", "reference": "NeuroPublic #4929", "source_commit": "9fa70597d98f91c850b549258bd5dbf9488caf45", "state": "open", "draft": true, "merged": false, "checks": [ { "name": "test", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "9fa70597d98f91c850b549258bd5dbf9488caf45" }, { "name": "lint", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "9fa70597d98f91c850b549258bd5dbf9488caf45" }, { "name": "regression", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "9fa70597d98f91c850b549258bd5dbf9488caf45" } ], "skipped_checks": [ "build-docker", "affected-tests" ], "detail": "Named exact-head CI completed successfully. The PR remains open, Draft and unmerged. Skipped checks were not evaluated. Session ownership and operating adoption were not established." }, { "id": "NB-PR-20261010-4932", "kind": "PR_METADATA", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "repository": "NeuroPublic", "reference": "NeuroPublic #4932", "source_commit": "3cc129f4a2675855843dc367ed8aadc5de3e20d0", "state": "open", "draft": true, "merged": false, "checks": [ { "name": "test", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "3cc129f4a2675855843dc367ed8aadc5de3e20d0" }, { "name": "lint", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "3cc129f4a2675855843dc367ed8aadc5de3e20d0" }, { "name": "regression", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "3cc129f4a2675855843dc367ed8aadc5de3e20d0" } ], "skipped_checks": [ "build-docker", "affected-tests" ], "detail": "Named exact-head CI completed successfully. The PR remains open, Draft and unmerged. Skipped checks were not evaluated. Session ownership and operating adoption were not established." }, { "id": "NB-PR-20261010-5084", "kind": "PR_METADATA", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "repository": "NeuroPublic", "reference": "NeuroPublic #5084", "source_commit": "e9a241aca95ffa8713fad5d56b2fc6280a0ffe75", "state": "open", "draft": true, "merged": false, "checks": [ { "name": "test", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "e9a241aca95ffa8713fad5d56b2fc6280a0ffe75" }, { "name": "lint", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "e9a241aca95ffa8713fad5d56b2fc6280a0ffe75" }, { "name": "regression", "status": "completed", "conclusion": "success", "source_commit": "e9a241aca95ffa8713fad5d56b2fc6280a0ffe75" } ], "skipped_checks": [ "build-docker" ], "detail": "Named exact-head CI completed successfully. The PR remains open, Draft and unmerged. Skipped checks were not evaluated. Session ownership and operating adoption were not established." } ], "claims": [ { "id": "NB-CF01", "title": "End-to-end evidence linkage", "scope": "research-to-authority-to-execution-to-accounting across engines", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/limits/0", "statement": "None of the 772 broker-accepted stock orders carries a decision identifier; no accepted order on any venue is linked to a research signal (0 of 4,466; only stock-brokerage orders have a rule that can link one); and no index rule yet records the authority behind a decision, so a governed decision cannot be counted. The research-to-authorized-execution-to-accounting path is not established." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF02", "title": "Accepted-order decision identity", "scope": "historical accepted stock-order population", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/development_scope/1/detail", "statement": "A daily lineage index (latest completed build 30 September) measures the path and a scheduled readiness run gates its first stage. None of the 772 broker-accepted stock orders carries a decision identifier yet, so no stock order links a decision to its accounting. A complete repeatable path is not yet established." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF03", "title": "Authority-event linkage", "scope": "decision-to-authority index linkage", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/next_acceptance_conditions/2", "statement": "Give authority events their own identifiers so a governed decision can be counted, and read the release-authority artifact beside the approval axis." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF04", "title": "DCA identity adoption", "scope": "DCA producer and natural consumer adoption", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.sha256", "sha256": "f3f85024f0a1a8a03285aa27b836130c038d2b0d020057650b85cbf94d7725ee", "pointer": "/earlier_advances/0/detail", "statement": "Merged and installed source contains identity minting. Observed live rows still lack decision IDs; runtime adoption is unresolved." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF05", "title": "Research readiness input failure", "scope": "one dated research readiness run", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/limits/1", "statement": "The latest research readiness run stopped at its data-panel lineage check with 17 of 42 factor checks failing, so no research observation started." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF06", "title": "Unread release-authority artifact", "scope": "release-authority observation access", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/limits/3", "statement": "The release-authority artifact was not read; this review makes no claim about central live release." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF07", "title": "Approval actor and grant time", "scope": "approval-axis dated observation", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/authority/0/boundary", "statement": "HTTP availability is not business readiness. The approval-axis value is a summary the health endpoint derives from the control plane's approval settings; no order is admitted or refused by reading that summary. The kill switch is reported separately. When the approval was last granted was not observed." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF08", "title": "Server-side risk refusal coverage", "scope": "specific refused execution context", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-27", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-27-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-27-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "b1021299dd28c133c3ffb121463722add5d6dbc3741c4a95f476a5ef7e35135b", "pointer": "/authority/3/detail", "statement": "Independent execution engines retain their own permissions, account contexts and gates. On the primary engine the core book remained sealed: identified order attempts on 26 September (KST) were refused by the server-side risk check and the core sell block." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF09", "title": "Autonomous submission conditions", "scope": "dated opt-in, lease and trial progression", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-27", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-27-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-27-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "b1021299dd28c133c3ffb121463722add5d6dbc3741c4a95f476a5ef7e35135b", "pointer": "/capabilities/1/detail", "statement": "The operator approval that the live-execution safety gate requires is granted, so the control plane reports its approval axis as open. The two autonomous-release opt-ins are off, and in the inspected half hour every autonomous submission attempt was skipped by a further gate (opt-in contract not active, admission lease not ready, certified trial not active). The portfolio kill switch is ARMED." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF10", "title": "Portfolio kill configuration versus trigger", "scope": "reported kill configuration and natural trigger", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/observed_states/kill_switch", "statement": "ARMED" }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF11", "title": "Kill/release event identity", "scope": "trigger/clear event identity and natural execution", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.sha256", "sha256": "f3f85024f0a1a8a03285aa27b836130c038d2b0d020057650b85cbf94d7725ee", "pointer": "/earlier_advances/1/detail", "statement": "Merged and installed source contains event identity. The inspected live ledger was empty; no event was triggered for this review." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF12", "title": "Portfolio target authority consumption", "scope": "target producer and authority consumer", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.sha256", "sha256": "f3f85024f0a1a8a03285aa27b836130c038d2b0d020057650b85cbf94d7725ee", "pointer": "/earlier_advances/2/detail", "statement": "Merged and installed source contains target identity. Runtime consumption and authority linkage remain unverified." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF13", "title": "Read-only HTTP deployment", "scope": "deployed console HTTP behavior", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.sha256", "sha256": "f3f85024f0a1a8a03285aa27b836130c038d2b0d020057650b85cbf94d7725ee", "pointer": "/earlier_advances/3/detail", "statement": "Merged source tightens signal history and raw linkage boundaries. Deployed HTTP behavior was not independently checked." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF14", "title": "Disabled inventory issuance", "scope": "manifest issuance and runtime adoption", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.sha256", "sha256": "f3f85024f0a1a8a03285aa27b836130c038d2b0d020057650b85cbf94d7725ee", "pointer": "/earlier_advances/4/detail", "statement": "Merged implementation remains disabled by default. Runtime manifest issuance and adoption remain unverified." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF15", "title": "Descendant-process cleanup", "scope": "actual descendant-process reaping", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-02", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-02-verification.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-02-verification.sha256", "sha256": "f215c307fcdd340194db32b7b8791147ad8f2da1158ca91c17cb716230535ddd", "pointer": "/changes/0/limit", "statement": "Controlled dependencies exercise the termination branches. Actual descendant-process reaping is not established." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF16", "title": "Absolute OS wall-clock bound", "scope": "all operating-system interactions", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-02", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-02-verification.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-02-verification.sha256", "sha256": "f215c307fcdd340194db32b7b8791147ad8f2da1158ca91c17cb716230535ddd", "pointer": "/changes/1/limit", "statement": "This bounds the tested cleanup read. It does not prove an absolute wall-clock bound for every operating-system interaction." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF17", "title": "Initialization first-failure visibility", "scope": "stale_daemon_detector.run_once_sync source before a domain state exists", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-04", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-04-engineering.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-04-engineering.sha256", "sha256": "64f5a5b70d7c616cab850fd5b84c4696f027cd18cad589ae40e09fa0d9f7804d", "pointer": "/first_failure/stage", "statement": "local_candidate" }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "OPEN_CONFIRMED", "basis": "NB-SOURCE-20261010-INIT", "detail": "The state-file selection omission is still present in the newly inspected source revision. The dated local repair remains preserved. This confirms a source gap only; operating occurrence and installation are UNKNOWN." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF18", "title": "Guardian main compatibility", "scope": "candidate versus the separately recorded main revision", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-04", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-04-engineering.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-04-engineering.sha256", "sha256": "64f5a5b70d7c616cab850fd5b84c4696f027cd18cad589ae40e09fa0d9f7804d", "pointer": "/guardian/later_main/compatibility", "statement": "unverified" }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "IMPLEMENTED_AWAITING_VERIFICATION", "basis": "NB-PR-20261010-5084", "detail": "The dated implementation candidate is still open and unmerged. Named exact-head lint, regression and test checks succeeded at this review. Current installation, natural execution and durable operating effect were not verified." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF19", "title": "Operating adoption and durable rollback", "scope": "installed revision, execution owner, natural completion and rollback", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-04", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-04-engineering.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-04-engineering.sha256", "sha256": "64f5a5b70d7c616cab850fd5b84c4696f027cd18cad589ae40e09fa0d9f7804d", "pointer": "/operating/unverified/2", "statement": "loaded_consumer_revision" }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF20", "title": "Research input measurement boundary", "scope": "input timestamp measurement, not research-quality certification", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.sha256", "sha256": "3c1fe70623b60f3d325b1e7bc9359c18236bf0cb84726e98399af6c221f75d97", "pointer": "/improvements/0/boundary", "statement": "All absent inputs remain missing; partial invalid inputs become unknown. Completeness covers only listed/discovered files, and older reports acquire no invented unknown count. Freshness, PIT correctness and research quality are not certified." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF21", "title": "UNKNOWN freshness denominator", "scope": "evaluable freshness states and observer coverage", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.sha256", "sha256": "3c1fe70623b60f3d325b1e7bc9359c18236bf0cb84726e98399af6c221f75d97", "pointer": "/improvements/1/after", "statement": "Only evaluable states enter the rate. Unknown, unparsed and unprobed rows remain visible and excluded from both sides; no evaluable observations yield 0/0 with no rate." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF22", "title": "Native and missing producer identities", "scope": "producer identity type and live DCA identities", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.sha256", "sha256": "3c1fe70623b60f3d325b1e7bc9359c18236bf0cb84726e98399af6c221f75d97", "pointer": "/improvements/2/boundary", "statement": "Direct nonstring native decision references are rejected. Normal opaque IDs, multiple children and content identities remain compatible. Already stringified producer IDs cannot reveal their original type; missing live DCA identities remain unresolved." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "IMPLEMENTED_AWAITING_VERIFICATION", "basis": "NB-PR-20261010-4923", "detail": "The dated implementation candidate is still open and unmerged. Named exact-head lint, regression and test checks succeeded at this review. Current installation, natural execution and durable operating effect were not verified." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF23", "title": "Heartbeat health interpretation", "scope": "process heartbeat versus completed application work", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-operational-proof-publication.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-operational-proof-publication.sha256", "sha256": "57d41bba421bbe3fe853c78153746e183ba755e90745432de7b165133fbf2624", "pointer": "/improvements/0/boundary", "statement": "Existing staleness and classification priorities remain. PID presence and a parsed timestamp do not establish installed code identity or successful application work." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "IMPLEMENTED_AWAITING_VERIFICATION", "basis": "NB-PR-20261010-4929", "detail": "The dated implementation candidate is still open and unmerged. Named exact-head lint, regression and test checks succeeded at this review. Current installation, natural execution and durable operating effect were not verified." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF24", "title": "Carried observation provenance", "scope": "carried/degraded status and original observation time", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-operational-proof-publication.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-operational-proof-publication.sha256", "sha256": "57d41bba421bbe3fe853c78153746e183ba755e90745432de7b165133fbf2624", "pointer": "/improvements/1/after", "statement": "Partial unreadable input follows the existing degraded path. Carried values retain degraded status, carry markers and their original observation time across repeated publication; legacy records acquire no fabricated provenance." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "IMPLEMENTED_AWAITING_VERIFICATION", "basis": "NB-PR-20261010-4916", "detail": "The dated implementation candidate is still open and unmerged. Named exact-head lint, regression and test checks succeeded at this review. Current installation, natural execution and durable operating effect were not verified." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF25", "title": "Recovery domain completion", "scope": "process/log health versus durable domain restoration", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-operational-proof-publication.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-operational-proof-publication.sha256", "sha256": "57d41bba421bbe3fe853c78153746e183ba755e90745432de7b165133fbf2624", "pointer": "/improvements/2/boundary", "statement": "HEALTHY remains process/log health, not proof of completed domain work or durable restoration. Naive health timestamps, malformed target evidence and legacy absence remain unknown." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "IMPLEMENTED_AWAITING_VERIFICATION", "basis": "NB-PR-20261010-4932", "detail": "The dated implementation candidate is still open and unmerged. Named exact-head lint, regression and test checks succeeded at this review. Current installation, natural execution and durable operating effect were not verified." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF26", "title": "Observer independence and coverage", "scope": "observer independence and full coverage census", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/limits/5", "statement": "Observer independence and complete coverage were not re-attested. Scheduled-task success alone does not establish either." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF27", "title": "Fleet clean-box recovery", "scope": "fleet-wide restore and formal close", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/limits/6", "statement": "NAS mounts and running services do not establish a verified fleet-wide clean-box recovery or a reconciled formal close." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF28", "title": "Historical transport failures", "scope": "two dated unavailable observation paths", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress.sha256", "sha256": "f3f85024f0a1a8a03285aa27b836130c038d2b0d020057650b85cbf94d7725ee", "pointer": "/observations/fleet/scope", "statement": "Name-resolution and host-key verification failures left two observation paths unavailable. Host health and external attestation were not established." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF29", "title": "Engine-specific market integration boundary", "scope": "engine-specific adapter paths and current product enablement", "historical": { "kind": "PUBLIC_PAGE_SNAPSHOT", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "artifact": "/architecture#market-coverage", "checksum": null, "sha256": "d3ecd19f7fa9b206bd6be788da9eae086a5e1452e056e0cec591a855d53cdc38", "pointer": null, "statement": "Generic KIS derivative scaffold branches are sealed. Source integrations do not establish every product is currently enabled." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF30", "title": "AVA server and inference verification", "scope": "AVA server implementation, residency and distributed inference", "historical": { "kind": "PUBLIC_PAGE_SNAPSHOT", "observed_on": "2026-10-10", "artifact": "/architecture#market-coverage", "checksum": null, "sha256": "d3ecd19f7fa9b206bd6be788da9eae086a5e1452e056e0cec591a855d53cdc38", "pointer": null, "statement": "AVA server implementation, model residency and current distributed inference were not verified by this source review." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF31", "title": "Historical CI and publication stage", "scope": "candidate publication and named exact-head CI only", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-09-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-09-30-engineering-progress-round2.sha256", "sha256": "3c1fe70623b60f3d325b1e7bc9359c18236bf0cb84726e98399af6c221f75d97", "pointer": "/improvements/0/publication", "statement": "Reviewed Draft #4916 updated; exact-head CI was queued or running at this review." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "HISTORICAL_ONLY", "basis": "NB-PR-20261010-4916", "detail": "The queued/running statement describes 30 September. On 10 October, named exact-head checks for NeuroPublic #4916, #4923, #4929, #4932 and #5084 had completed successfully, while all five PRs remained open, Draft and unmerged. The fleet-brain #1500 latest state was not inspected." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF32", "title": "Historical stale ledgers", "scope": "dated domestic ledger and rotation freshness", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-08-30", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-08-30-current.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-08-30-current.sha256", "sha256": "78b1868fd65168c2eda6cacd43de3e6f31b0e27ee75e01f8b08fa1c75161176f", "pointer": "/open_ledgers/4/detail", "statement": "One domestic order ledger has no declared freshness ceiling." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF33", "title": "Replay and effect remeasurement", "scope": "authority attribution, replay and effect totals", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-01", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-01-system-review.sha256", "sha256": "399267ec9e1d081ddc33d2a42f13e0144038718a62fc2fd469db621258bbe252", "pointer": "/limits/4", "statement": "Authority-surface attribution, replay equivalence and remediation-effect totals were not re-measured. August figures remain historical evidence." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." }, { "id": "NB-CF34", "title": "External reproduction and attestation", "scope": "independent reproduction of private execution", "historical": { "kind": "ORIGINAL_JSON", "observed_on": "2026-10-02", "artifact": "/evidence/2026-10-02-verification.json", "checksum": "/evidence/2026-10-02-verification.sha256", "sha256": "f215c307fcdd340194db32b7b8791147ad8f2da1158ca91c17cb716230535ddd", "pointer": "/reproduction_boundary", "statement": "The local result is tied to private source and test bytes. Public JSON and SHA-256 identify this disclosure; they do not independently reproduce or attest to the private execution. The website claim checks can be run from the website repository." }, "current": { "checked_on": "2026-10-10", "status": "UNKNOWN", "basis": null, "detail": "No new observation in this audit establishes the current operating state for this claim. The dated finding remains available; UNKNOWN is neither closure nor confirmation of a present defect." }, "next_verification": "An identified system owner must provide a commit-pinned observation for this exact scope before operating closure can be published." } ] }